Creativity Isn't Where Learning Begins. It's Where Learning Is Revealed.

Sport is unpredictable. No situation ever repeats exactly. This reality demands that athletes become effective problem-solvers who can adapt in real time. In short, they must develop the capacity to perform inside complexity without being directed. This essential capability is what I define in Coach by Design as: Creativity. The coach shouting from the sideline or sending messages onto the field simply cannot match the speed required for in-the-moment decision-making. Athletes must absorb information from the environment, process it rapidly, and respond appropriately.

Creativity isn't something you can ask for.

Nor does it appear the moment you stop giving direction. It has to be earned. The Learning Design Matrix™— the framework at the heart of Coach by Design—shows how creativity emerges through the interaction of two elements that shape every learning environment: structure and control.

Understanding Structure

Structure is the way the environment is organised, including the tasks, constraints, and opportunities for action available to the learner. There is physical and cultural structure in every learning environment.

From Coach by Design:

“Imagine walking into three different environments. A wide-open field, a fitness gym, and a skatepark. Each shapes the actions and perceptions available to learners in their own way. The open field offers almost complete freedom. There are no clear boundaries, no obvious suggestions of how to act. Only space and possibility. The gym, with its marked zones, mirrors, and rows of specialised equipment, communicates order and purpose. Its structure signals the routines to follow, the techniques to perfect, and the standards to meet. The skatepark sits somewhere in between. Its ramps, rails, and bowls provide opportunity but no specific prescription. Each feature invites autonomy and experimentation, allowing learners to choose their own challenges, adapt, and express their style within the structure the park provides. This is structure in action. Structure is a framework that shapes what is possible in a learning environment. It influences not only what people can do, but also how they think, feel, and interact. Structure includes the physical spaces, equipment, and technology in an environment. And it lives in the invisible forces of culture — the language people use, the rituals they share, and the unspoken norms that guide behaviour. These elements signal what matters, who belongs, and how learning is expected to unfold.”

Understanding Control

Control refers to the amount of external force applied to direct a learner’s perceptions and actions within the learning environment. It is not a fixed setting. It’s a dial. You turn it up or down depending on the learner, the moment, and the outcome you’re aiming for.

From Coach by Design:

“The most skilful coaches and teachers don’t cling to control. Instead, they learn to release it when it matters most. That evening at the BMX track, I saw what that looked like in practice. No one was orchestrating the learning, correcting mistakes, or giving constant instruction. Instead, a small group of riders experimented, reflected, and refined their way to effective learning. The coach’s role, if there was one, was invisible. It was embedded in the environment itself.”

Understanding structure and control independently is useful. But learning environments are never built from one without the other. It is the way they interact that ultimately shapes what learners experience.

Designing for Creativity

The Learning Design Matrix™ combines structure and control to create four distinct learning environments. Each offers something different to the learner, and each has a role to play in development. The fourth quadrant (low structure, low control) is Creativity. It would be tempting to assume that Creativity is where every session should begin. It isn't. Creativity depends on everything that comes before it. Before athletes can make effective decisions on their own, they need experiences that challenge them to build skill, adaptability, confidence, judgement, and awareness. Creativity isn't the absence of learning. It's where prior learning is revealed.

From Coach by Design:

“The Creativity quadrant is where autonomy, imagination, and identity take centre stage. Structure exists, but it’s open and often learner generated. Control is low, allowing individuals to follow their curiosity, test ideas, and create meaning through action. It is a place where learning unfolds through doing, watching, failing, and trying again. While it might look chaotic from the outside, the thoughtful design of the environment invites possibility and potential paths for progress. In these environments, feedback often comes from the environment or from peers. Coaches in this space act more like gardeners than guides or directors. They create a space for emergence, then take a big step back and let it happen.”

Creativity is not where learning begins.

It is where everything that has come before is integrated, tested, and expressed in the complexity of the moment.

From Coach by Design:

“Creativity is the most demanding environment a learner can step into. It asks them to decide without being told, adapt without guidance, and act without reassurance. By the time learners arrive in this quadrant, they have already been directed in their execution, guided through discovery, and unsettled just enough to become aware of their own habits and assumptions. Creativity is what comes next. The environment no longer prescribes what to do or how to do it. Instead, it offers invitations. Space. Possibility. Learners are trusted to bring what they know into the moment and decide how to act. This is where skill, perception, emotion, and identity converge.”

One of the biggest misconceptions in coaching is that creativity comes from giving athletes complete freedom. In reality, creativity is something we prepare athletes for. It grows when we carefully balance structure and control, gradually handing responsibility to the learner as they develop the skills, confidence, and judgement to thrive without us. That's the central idea behind Coach by Design. It's not another book about drills or session plans. It's a different way of thinking about how learning happens and how the environments we create quietly shape who young people become.

“In our attempt to be technically perfect, we had engineered the joy out of sport. Our environment was built for control, not discovery. For compliance, not creativity.”

Dr Craig Harrison, Coach by Design

If you'd like to explore the Learning Design Matrix™ and learn how to intentionally design environments that develop more curious, adaptable, and creative learners, follow the link below. I (Craig) hope it changes the way you think about coaching as much as writing it changed the way I do.

Want to discuss anything you’ve read? Email us at [email protected]. We’d love to hear from you!

Want to share the Deep Dive with friends? Just send them the link below to subscribe